Procedure for reviewing


To ensure honest and unbiased assessment of papers submitted to the Editorial Board of the 'Annales. Ethics in Economic Life' / 'Annales. Etyka w życiu gospodarczym', they are evaluated according to the review procedure recommended by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education in Poland.

All the papers are assessed by two independent reviewers who are not affiliated with the research centres of the authors. The evaluation is carried out in accordance with the procedure of double anonymity of the reviewer and the author of the article (double-blind review process). In cases of papers written in a foreign language, at least one of the reviewers is affiliated to a research centre located in a country other than that from which the author comes.

The reviews are provided in writing. The reviewer concludes categorically whether an article is ready for publishing, ought to be corrected or should be rejected. On the basis of the reviews the Editorial Board takes a decision to publish, reject or send the paper back to the author to make necessary corrections.

The authors can reply to the reviews. These replies are considered by the Editorial Board.


The review form to download

List of reviewers in 2018:

    prof. Aniela Dylus, Cardinal Stefan Wyszyñski University in Warsaw
    prof. Carlos Figueroa, Ithaca College (USA)
    prof. Janina Go³dów-LegiêdŸ, University of Lodz
    prof. Erica Grodzki, Lynn University (USA)
    prof. Nikkie S. Hodgson, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley (USA)
    prof. Jennifer L. Lemanski, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley (USA)
    prof. Anna Lewicka-Strza³ecka, Polish Academy of Sciences
    prof. Barbara Pogonowska, Poznan University of Economics
    prof. Lyon Rathbun, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley (USA)
    prof. Sharaf N. Rehman, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley (USA)
    prof. Przemys³aw Rotengruber, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan
    prof. Grzegorz Szulczewski, Warsaw School of Economics

List of reviewers in 2017:

    prof. Jędrzej Chumiński, Wroclaw University of Economics
    prof. Aniela Dylus, Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński University in Warsaw
    prof. Ewa Gruszewska, University of Białystok
    prof. Anna Lewicka-Strzałecka, PhD, Polish Academy of Sciences
    rev. prof. Biju Michael SDB, Salesian Pontifical University, Jerusalem, Israel
    prof. Maciej Miszewski, University of Economics in Katowice
    prof. Barbara Pogonowska, Poznan University of Economics
    prof. Sharaf N. Rehman, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley (USA)
    prof. Przemysław Rotengruber, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan
    prof. Jacek Sójka, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan
    prof. Grzegorz Szulczewski, Warsaw School of Economics
    dr Jacek Wallusch, Institute of Cliometrics and Transition Studies